The Withdrawal of the EU and the Member States from the Energy Charter Treaty: Who will bear international responsibility for breaches of the Treaty?

Energy transition| Global transition

The legal study investigates what would happen to EU member states that remain in the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) and implement binding EU acts (like a directive) or a court ruling after the EU has withdrawn from the ECT.

The study finds convincing evidence that EU member states could be held responsible by an arbitration tribunal under the ECT for implementing binding EU acts and could be forced to pay compensation to an investor over a breach of provisions in the ECT. This would also be the case, if the member state had no choice but to implement the EU act. The authors recommend that states that want to minimise financial risks and avoid having to pay compensation for implementing binding EU decisions should withdraw from the ECT together with the EU.

Download the full study here.

RELATED NEWS_

Policy Briefing

Letter to the EU Heads of States and Governments: The Clean Industrial Deal & Competitiveness

We are writing ahead of the European Council 17-18 October meeting, in which the EU’s competitiveness agenda will be discussed.
In light of the forthcoming ‘Clean Industrial Deal’ (CID), the best way to preserve the EU’s long-term competitiveness is an EU green industrial strategy centred around the European Green Deal and its targets, which stimulates the production of net-zero technologies, ends our fossil fuel dependence and reduces our energy and material demand.

Read More »